The Dead Auteur Society

Reel 042

Still from Se7en

Nominated by Yasin July 2024

Se7en

Directed by
David Fincher
Released
1995
Screened

The verdict

10.37 / 11.5

Mean of 5 reviewers · 90.17% of a perfect score

Highlights

  1. 1A Rank

    #3

    of 42 films screened

  2. 2A Top category

    Casting

    88% of the category max

  3. 3A Consensus

    Some Debate

    σ 0.65 across reviewer totals

  4. 4A The Fan

    Yasin

    Highest total · 11.2

  5. 5A The Cynic

    Zelie

    Lowest total · 9.65

  6. 6A The Specialist

    Krishan

    Themes · 100% of max

Plot synopsis

The story follows two detectives, the veteran William Somerset (Morgan Freeman) and the young, impulsive David Mills (Brad Pitt), who are paired together to solve a series of gruesome murders in an unnamed city that is perpetually rain-soaked and dreary. Somerset, on the verge of retirement, is deeply knowledgeable and philosophical, while Mills is eager and hot-headed, newly transferred to the city with his wife, Tracy (Gwyneth Paltrow).

The detectives discover that the murders are intricately planned and each represents a punishment for one of the seven deadly sins: gluttony, greed, sloth, lust, pride, envy, and wrath. The first murder involves an obese man forced to eat until his stomach ruptures, representing gluttony. The second victim, a wealthy defense attorney, is bled to death for the sin of greed.

As Somerset and Mills delve deeper into the case, they realize they are dealing with a serial killer whose meticulous planning and knowledge of scripture and classical texts suggest profound derangement yet intelligent design. The killer, John Doe (Kevin Spacey), eventually turns himself in, covered in the blood of an unidentified victim.

Doe offers to lead the detectives to the final two bodies, initiating a tense climax. In a remote desert location, a delivery van arrives with a package, which, upon opening by Mills, is revealed to contain the severed head of his pregnant wife, Tracy, representing envy (Doe’s envy of Mills’ normal life) and preparing to incite Mills to embody wrath.

Doe explains that his plan was to illustrate the presence of sin around everyone and punish the wicked directly through his acts. Confronted with his wife’s head and Doe’s taunting, Mills is consumed by rage and kills Doe, thereby completing the series of seven sins.

Themes:

“Se7en” explores themes of good versus evil, the nature of sin, and the philosophical challenge of retaining one’s moral compass in a world filled with darkness and despair. The film is noted for its exploration of the apathy and jadedness that can come from confronting evil on a daily basis, which is contrasted with the idealism and emotional responses that stem from personal involvement. The ending starkly poses the question of justice versus vengeance and whether evil can truly be understood or countered by good.

“Se7en” is widely regarded as a cinematic masterpiece for its atmospheric direction, tight screenplay, and compelling performances, leaving a lasting impact on the thriller genre with its bleak outlook and moral complexity.

Category by category How scoring works

  1. Enjoyable 5 / 5
  2. Plot 1.72 / 2
  3. Acting 1.3 / 1.5
  4. Camera 0.86 / 1
  5. Themes 0.43 / 0.5
  6. Music 0.32 / 0.5
  7. Casting 0.44 / 0.5
  8. Wildcard +0.3 ±0.5

The ledger

ReviewerEnjoyablePlotActingCameraThemesMusicCastingWildcardTotal
Yasin Fan521.310.50.40.50.511.2
Muhammad51.81.50.90.40.30.50.510.9
Becca51.61.30.850.350.40.40.210.1
Krishan51.61.30.80.50.10.50.210
Zelie Cynic51.61.10.750.40.40.30.19.65
Mean51.721.30.860.430.320.440.310.37
Max521.510.50.50.5±0.511.5

From the archive

Keep flipping

All films