The Dead Auteur Society

Reel 042

Still from First Cow

Nominated by Tommy February 2023

First Cow

Directed by
Kelly Reichardt
Released
2019
Screened

The verdict

8.93 / 11.5

Mean of 4 reviewers · 77.65% of a perfect score

Highlights

  1. 1A Rank

    #24

    of 42 films screened

  2. 2A Top category

    Camera

    88% of the category max

  3. 3A Consensus

    High Agreement

    σ 0.52 across reviewer totals

  4. 4A The Fan

    Muhammad

    Highest total · 9.65

  5. 5A The Cynic

    Zelie

    Lowest total · 8.45

  6. 6A The Specialist

    Zelie

    Casting · 100% of max

Plot synopsis

First Cow (2019) is an American drama film set in the 1820s in the Oregon Territory. The story revolves around two men, Otis “Cookie” Figowitz, a skilled cook, and King-Lu, a Chinese immigrant. Both men are seeking their fortune in the untamed wilderness of the Pacific Northwest.

When they come across the territory’s first and only dairy cow, owned by a wealthy landowner, they devise a plan to steal its milk under the cover of night. Using the stolen milk, Cookie makes delicious “oily cakes,” which they sell at the local market, quickly gaining popularity and success. However, their secret operation becomes increasingly risky as their business thrives and draws more attention.

The film explores themes of friendship, ambition, and the pursuit of the American Dream while providing a glimpse into the lives of early settlers in the Pacific Northwest. The slow-paced, atmospheric storytelling is complemented by stunning cinematography and a focus on the simplicity and beauty of nature.

Category by category How scoring works

  1. Enjoyable 5 / 5
  2. Plot 0.95 / 2
  3. Acting 0.94 / 1.5
  4. Camera 0.88 / 1
  5. Themes 0.31 / 0.5
  6. Music 0.39 / 0.5
  7. Casting 0.43 / 0.5
  8. Wildcard +0.04 ±0.5

The ledger

ReviewerEnjoyablePlotActingCameraThemesMusicCastingWildcardTotal
Muhammad Fan51.10.7510.40.50.40.59.65
Krishan51.310.850.20.250.4-0.18.9
Yasin51.110.750.30.40.4-0.258.7
Zelie Cynic50.310.90.350.40.508.45
Mean50.950.940.880.310.390.430.048.93
Max521.510.50.50.5±0.511.5

From the archive

Keep flipping

All films